Trump's Disastrous Deportation Plan

A mass deportation of all the undocumented immigrants, as Trump has vowed to do if elected President, would likely be a humanitarian disaster.  Already, an estimated half of all undocumented aliens detained by ICE are housed in private prisons.  Additionally hundreds of those detainees were wrongly detained even though they were legal US citizens.  In one case, a US citizen named Hector Veloz was detained by ICE for over a year, all the while Veloz did everything he could, including presenting his birth certificate to the immigration courts.  Additionally, widespread reports of abuses of those detainees, regardless of their legal status, has also been reported.  If Trumps plans were implemented, I believe we would be seeing a modern day Trail of Tears for the undocumented and wrongfully deported US citizens.  But Trump's plan would be a huge windfall for the private prisons, who would no doubt milk such a deportation for all its worth -- including delaying the deportation process and hold inmates longer than necessary in order to keep our public dollars flowing that are tied to those inmates remaining in those private prisons.

The estimated total number of  illegal aliens that would be deported under Trump's plan is 11 million, coincidentally, 11 million is the estimated total number of human victims of Hitler's Holocaust.  Remember, to handle that volume people, the Nazis had to use freight trains to haul such a vast number of individuals.  But, unlike the Holocaust, we still would require a system of due process to determine  for each one of those 11 million whether or not they were indeed here illegally.  One wonders if the initial number of individuals rounded up might be much greater than 11 million.  That is, perhaps everyone with dark skin, speaking with a Latino accent would be rounded up as a suspected illegal alien to be sorted out at a later date.

Until all those individuals can be processed and their cases reviewed and heard before a magistrate, they would of course have to be held somewhere.  Since our prisons are already overcrowded, some sort of makeshift detention, or concentration camps would have to be set up across the country -- complete with barbed wire, armed guard towers, dogs and spotlights.  And, as it is currently, it is not as though our courts and judges and public defense lawyers have all sorts of time on their hands with everyone looking for something to do.  So, in order to process all those millions, many detainees would likely have to wait years if not decades to have their case heard.  A detainee could be a full U.S.Citizen, but not be able to see anyone for years to simply hear their case.  They would be trapped in one of the camps, knowing they are innocent but not be able to prove that to anyone who could get them out.  There is often no way of knowing right away who is here illegally and who isn't.  Those here illegally, perhaps by illegal means, are able to obtain many of the same documents that would appear on its face to prove citizenship, as legal citizens have.  It is not as though the undocumented aliens have a sign on their forehead flashing 'illegal alien' that ICE agents can use to sort them from those here legally.  As a result, some sort of manual judicial sorting process involving one on one meetings with lawyers and judges needs to be performed for each and every detainee in order to determine citizen status.        

Of further concern, given Trump's notorious thin skin, if he might utilize those deportee detention camps as de facto political prison camps.  Maybe Trump will wield his power to make his critics suffer from an administrative 'oops' that result in them being suspected of being here illegally and have to be sent to a camp for further processing.  Such a victim may cry that they suspect they are a political prisoner to the clerk processing them in the camp.  The clerk might then respond that the inmate will have their case heard before a judge in approximately 5 years if everything goes smoothly.  Meanwhile, here is your uniform, your number and a map to your tent.

I find it rather ironic that some of Trump's most fervent supporters are Internet and Radio conspiracy theory celebrities like Alex Jones that have warned us for years that we can't trust the federal government because they are bent on imprisoning us in mass Fema camps.  Who does Jones and company think will carry out Trump's deportation plan?  The Federal Government will, of course.  Why do they suddenly think the government can be trusted to fairly, and justly carry out such an enormous mass arrest, detention and processing of human beings?  But regardless of anyone's general trust or mistrust of the government,  there clearly is no means to fairly and justly carry out Trump's deportation plan.  And the history of ICE even under the normal circumstances of a relatively small number of deportations, has shown itself to be unreliable and prone to miscarriage of justice and abuse in the detention and processing of detainees.  The detention and processing of millions can only lead to a nightmare scenario as bad or worse than any warning ever painted by even the most imaginative conspiracy theorist.